Philadelphia Union — Chris Seitz; Cristian Arrieta, Danny Califf, Michael Orozco Fiscal, Jordan Harvey; Stefani Miglioranzi, Fred, Eduardo Coudet, Justin Mapp; Sebastien Le Toux, Alejandro Moreno
Bench: Brad Knighton, Andrew Jacobson, Danny Mwanga, Amobi Okugo, Toni Stahl, Jack McInerney, Kyle Nakazawa
Columbus Crew – Will Hesmer; Danny O’Rourke, Andy Iro, Chad Marshall; Frankie Hejduk, Emmanuel Ekpo, Shaun Francis, Brian Carroll; Emilio Renteria, Guillermo Barros Schelotto, Jason Garey
Bench: Jed Zayner, Dilly Duka, Steven Lenhart, Duncan Oughton, Eric Brunner, Leandre Griffit, Andy Gruenebaum